Coke and Pepsi Responsible for "Trashing America," Hurting Taxpayers and Environment

IMMEDIATE RELEASE
April 16, 2002
Contact: Lance King - (703) 536-7282
or (706) 613-7121

Coke and Pepsi Responsible for "Trashing America," Hurting Taxpayers and Environment

NEW YORK (APRIL 16, 2002) -- Coke and Pepsi are responsible for a dramatic increase in packaging waste over the last ten years, hurting taxpayers and the environment. Launching a new national campaign with an advertisement on the New York Times 'Op Ed' page today, two national organizations charge Coke and Pepsi with "trashing America."

"Coke and Pepsi waste from used aluminum cans, plastic and glass bottles doubled between 1992 and 2000, according to industry data. A financial incentive is urgently needed to reverse the decline in bottle and can recycling rates. Ten states with refundable deposits on beverage containers recycle more bottles and cans than the other 40 states put together, at almost no cost to taxpayers," Pat Franklin, executive director of the Container Recycling Institute, said today.

"We've chosen to launch a new national campaign in New York City today because decisions here about handling beverage containers have national implications.

New York State is one of ten states with a beverage container deposit law, popularly known as the bottle bill. Deposit laws achieve the highest rates of recycling in the nation - 78 percent on average. Coke and Pepsi have fought these laws for more than 30 years, and want to roll back this sound environmental policy," Franklin said.

The Container Recycling Institute is a national, nonprofit research and education organization, based in Arlington, Virginia. It received a grant from the Florence Fund for the issue advocacy advertisement placed in the New York Times today.

"We believe that companies producing and selling beverages must be made accountable for their packaging waste. The principle is known as producer responsibility, which is a growing trend in policies adopted around the world," GrassRoots Recycling Network Executive Director Bill Sheehan said.

"Our goal is achieving an 80 percent national recycling rate for aluminum cans, plastic and glass bottles, roughly double the current rate," Sheehan said.

"While litter and landfill waste are the first ways most people think about recycling of beverage containers, the environmental footprint left by throwing away millions of bottles and cans every hour is really much bigger than that. We have a choice to pursue an 80 percent national recycling rate, and save the equivalent of 640 million barrels of oil in the next decade, or leave a legacy of waste," CRI Senior Policy Analyst Lance King said.

The Container Recycling Institute and GrassRoots Recycling Network are launching a new Internet website today as part of their joint campaign: www.saveabottle.org.

On Wednesday, April 17 leaders from both organizations plan to carry their message to The Coca-Cola Company annual meeting at Madison Square Garden, where they will urge shareholders to support a recycling resolution.

In Hawaii, the Legislature is poised to adopt the first new state deposit law in 16 years, but Coke and Pepsi are leading the battle to defeat it between now and when the legislators adjourn on May 2nd.

"Earlier this month, the beverage and grocery industries waged the first successful campaign to repeal a deposit law - the nation's only local deposit ordinance in Columbia, Missouri," King said. "The most disturbing aspect is the way corporate money and a campaign based on deception corrupted the democratic process."

"Next week, CRI and GRRN will carry concerns about Coke and Pepsi waste to the nation's capital. We will advocate a new policy approach, based on producer responsibility for product and packaging waste," Sheehan said.

The Container Recycling Institute plans to release a series of reports in coming months on the growing beverage container waste problem, deposit laws worldwide, and an examination of the 30-year war waged by Coke and Pepsi against deposit laws," Franklin said.

For more information about the Container Recycling Institute, visit the Internet at: www.container-recycling.org and www.bottlebill.info.

For more information on GRRN, visit the Internet at: www.grrn.org.

Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo shareholders can vote for the recycling resolutions by going to: www.saveabottle.org and selecting the proxy voting links.

New Legislation by Senator Jeffords Holds Beverage Industry Responsible for Recycling 80 Percent of Bottles and Cans

IMMEDIATE RELEASE
April 22, 2002
Contact: Lance King - (703) 536-7282
or (703) 276-9800

New Legislation by Senator Jeffords Holds Beverage Industry Responsible for Recycling 80 Percent of Bottles and Cans


Energy Saved Would Meet Electricity Needs of 5 Million Households

WASHINGTON, DC (APRIL 22, 2002) -- Environmental leaders joined U.S. Senator Jim Jeffords (I-VT) today on Capitol Hill to support new legislation holding the beverage industry responsible for increasing bottle and can recycling.

"More than 114 billion beverage containers were thrown away rather than recycled in 1999, a 50 percent increase in bottle and can waste since 1992. Marketing strategies and packaging choices made by beverage companies are key factors in the growing waste problem," Pat Franklin, Executive Director of the Container Recycling Institute, said. CRI is a national, nonprofit organization based in Arlington, VA.

"Senator Jeffords is taking a new approach by setting a national performance standard for beverage container recycling-achieving an 80 percent national recycling rate, and by holding beverage companies directly responsible for meeting that standard," Franklin said.

Under the Jeffords bill, the nation's soft drink, beer and other beverage companies would be required to develop plans using a 10-cent refundable deposit on beverage containers to achieve the national standard. Plans would be submitted to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for approval.

Environmental leaders from the Container Recycling Institute, Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund, Friends of the Earth, GrassRoots Recycling Network and the Natural Resources Defense Council joined Senator Jeffords at the news conference.

"The beverage industry knows what works to recover containers because they invented the deposit system for refillable glass bottles, and they operate the system in the 10 U.S. states where they are required to do it. Those 10 states with deposits recycle more bottles and cans than all the other 40 states together," said Bill Sheehan, Executive Director of the GrassRoots Recycling Network, which is based in Athens, Georgia.

"What's new about the Jeffords approach is that it will result in a system designed by beverage producers, not imposed on them. It allows industry do what industry does best, design a cost-effective system that gets the job done. Government does what government does best -- setting standards in the public interest, monitoring progress and ensuring compliance," Sheehan said.

The 10 states with deposit laws are California, Connecticut, Delaware, Iowa, Massachusetts, Maine, New York, Michigan, Oregon, and Vermont.

"The federal government has established performance standards in laws such as the Clean Air Act. What Senator Jeffords proposes is good for the environment and for business, because industry knows what is expected and has the flexibility to develop the most efficient recycling systems," Friends of the Earth President Brent Blackwelder said. FOE is an international environmental organization based in Washington, D.C.

CRI Senior Policy Analyst Lance King explained two key factors contributing to the waste problem. "Marketing beverages for away from home consumption and the shift to plastic bottles have fueled the beverage container waste problem," King said.

"Achieving an 80 percent recycling rate would produce major benefits in energy conservation, saving the equivalent of 640 million barrels of oil over a ten year period or enough electricity to meet the needs of 5 million households a year," King said.

"Requiring a 10-cent refundable deposit would lead to a doubling of the national beverage container recycling rate within the next several years. Michigan has a 10-cent deposit and the highest recycling rate in the nation - 95 percent or higher since its deposit law was passed," Franklin said.

CRI and GRRN cited a new study by businesses and environmentalists showing that deposit systems result in the highest level of recycling - with 422 bottles and cans recycled per capita, compared to only 127 beverage containers recycled per capita through curbside recycling in non-deposit states.*

"Vermont's bottle deposit law has been in place now for 30 years. As is the case in other 'Bottle Bill' states, the program is among the most successful and popular of Vermont's environmental laws," said Joan Mulhern, legislative counsel for Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund, the nation's largest nonprofit environmental law firm. "It's time for Congress to apply the successful deposit system across the nation."

For more information, visit GRRN and CRI on the Internet at: www.grrn.org/beverage/deposits/ and www.container-recycling.org.



* Businesses and Environmentalists Allied for Recycling (BEAR) commissioned the report, Understanding Beverage Container Recycling, A Value Chain Assessment prepared for the Multi-Stakeholder Recovery Project (MSRP), by R.W. Beck, released on January 16, 2002. The BEAR report is available on the Internet at: www.globalgreen.org/BEAR.

Coca-Cola Faces Recycling Challenge

NEWS RELEASE
April 17, 2001

Contact: Lance King (703) 536-7282 or (706) 613-7121

Coca-Cola Faces Recycling Challenge

76 investors, public officials, businesses, environmental and community leaders urge support for shareholder resolution, item 5 at Coke's annual meeting.

NEW YORK, NY (April 17, 2001) - Making an appeal to The Coca-Cola Company's board of directors, an environmental group released today a letter signed by a diverse coalition of leaders urging support for setting recycling goals and developing a plan to meet them.

"Investors, public officials, businesses, environmental and community leaders share a common objective, which is halting the wasting of Coke bottles and cans," said Bill Sheehan, national network coordinator for the Athens, Georgia-based GrassRoots Recycling Network.

"Shareholders can send the Coke board of directors a clear message by voting for Item 5, the recycling resolution, at the April 18 annual shareholder meeting in Wilmington, Delaware," Sheehan said. "For information on the resolution visit our Internet web site at www.grrn.org."

Domini Social Investments, based in New York, explained why it is co-sponsoring the Coca-Cola shareholder resolution. "In our view, a firm's commitment to responsible management of its waste stream is an essential component of sound corporate management, and a strong contributor to shareholder value. As the industry leader, we believe Coke has a responsibility to develop a more comprehensive recycling policy with clear goals that raise the bar for the beverage industry," said Adam Kanzer, general counsel for Domini Social Investments.

Shareholder groups have been discussing recycling concerns with Coca-Cola management for two years. The recycling resolution calls upon the company to achieve specific recycling targets by January 1, 2005: using 25 percent recycled plastic to make new bottles and reaching an 80 percent national recycling rate for bottles and cans.

"We are encouraged by Coke's responsiveness to our concerns, and hope that shareholders will take this opportunity to send management a further message of encouragement by voting to support our resolution," Kanzer said. "We hold 717,300 shares of the Coca-Cola Company in the Domini Social Equity Fund's (Ticker: DSEFX) socially and environmentally screened portfolio."

Pat Franklin, executive director of the Arlington, Virginia-based Container Recycling Institute said, "In the 24 hours from releasing this appeal to Coca-Cola's board of directors to the vote at the shareholders meeting tomorrow, more than 54 million empty Coke soft drink bottles and cans will be thrown away. It's a terrible waste of precious natural resources and the energy needed to make more plastic and aluminum beverage containers."

Coca-Cola Shareholders Vote On Recycling - 'Better Than Expected'

News Release

April 18, 2001

Contact:

Lance King (703) 536-7282 or (706) 613-7121

Coca-Cola Shareholders Vote On Recycling - 'Better Than Expected'

88.9 million shares voted 'Yes' on recycling means supporters can bring measure back again, according to rules set by U.S. SEC

WILMINGTON, DELAWARE (April 18, 2001) - Investors with 88.9 million shares of Coca-Cola stock, worth more than 4 billion dollars, voted to support a shareholder resolution on recycling at the company's annual meeting today

Supporters of the recycling resolution secured enough support to bring the proposal back again next year, according to U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission rules governing shareholder proposals.

"We did better than expected. When you combine the yes votes and those who abstained, roughly 10 percent of the votes went against the Coca-Cola management's recommendation opposing the recycling resolution. That's an excellent result for a first vote on any shareholder resolution," said Lance King, speaking on behalf of environmental groups and individual investors supporting the recycling proposal (Item 5) on Coke's agenda.

Conrad MacKerron, representing the Education Foundation of America and Walden Asset Management, co-sponsors of the shareholder resolution, made the presentation in support of the shareholder proposal. The non-binding proposal calls for Coca-Cola to achieve two specific recycling goals by January 1, 2005:

  • Make plastic bottles with 25 percent recycled plastic; and
  • Take steps to achieve an 80 percent recycling rate for Coke bottles and cans.

"Recycling rates for beverages sold by Coca-Cola and its competitors dropped dramatically in recent years, as plastic bottles and other throwaway beverage containers proliferate," said Pat Franklin, a Coke shareholder and executive director of the nonprofit Container Recycling Institute, based in Arlington, Virginia.

Coca-Cola Chairman and CEO Douglas Daft made two significant announcements in response to the shareholder proposal on recycling. First, Daft said that Coca-Cola plans to use 10 percent recycled plastic in its bottles by 2005. Second, Daft said Coke is working with a newly formed alliance called BEAR - Businesses and Environmentalists Allied for Recycling.

In a question and answer session, Bill Sheehan of the GrassRoots Recycling Network noted that Coke uses 25 percent recycled plastic in other countries, such as Daft's native Australia, and Sheehan asked "why not in the United States?"

Sheehan also presented a letter in support of the shareholder resolution on recycling, addressed to the Coca-Cola Board of Directors, and signed by 76 investors, public officials, businesses, environmental and community leaders.

Bob Woodall, an Atlanta-shareholder and executive director of Waste Not Georgia, said after the vote: "Unless a financial incentive is established, like the refundable deposits in 10 states with bottle bill laws, Coke will find it difficult or impossible to meet the goal of making plastic bottles with 10 percent recycled plastic."

Institutional investors co-sponsoring the shareholder recycling resolution called on Coca-Cola to stop opposing bottle bills or come up with another method to achieve the 80 percent recycling rate, which is the current average in states with refundable deposits.

"The vote today assures shareholders that recycling will stay on the agenda in discussion with top management at Coca-Cola and can be brought back again next year, if necessary. Coca-Cola is beginning to address the problem," King said.

Pepsi, by contrast, is doing nothing to address these problems and fought unsuccessfully before the SEC to block a similar shareholder recycling proposal, according to the environmental groups. The Pepsi shareholder vote is scheduled May 2 in Dallas, Texas.

Popular Links

  • Publications
  • CRI Memberships
  • Data Archive

New beverage container deposit program bills. Expansion and repeal proposals. Sales, redemption rate and waste trends. Refillable bottle infrastructure. Extended producer responsibility.

CRI covers them all – and more – as the leading source of original research, objective analysis and responsible advocacy on the recycling of beverage containers.

Get the latest insights on our Publications and Letters and Briefings pages. Also visit our California DRS page for details on important upgrades made to the state’s beverage container deposit return program, but also the need for additional program reforms – in large part due to misreporting of its fund balance, which diligent work by CRI helped bring to light.

Plus, sign up for our Weekly Headlines e-newsletter for the latest beverage container deposit and recycling industry news, and check back for new information as we continue working to make North America a global model for the collection and quality recycling of packaging materials.

CRI offers a variety of membership and partnership options that provide a wide range of benefits, including complimentary registration to CRI webinars, technical assistance and more.

Review the options on our Memberships & Partnerships page and join us!

Find a wealth of data on metrics such as recycling rates, waste and sales for all beverage container types on CRI’s Data Archive page. Charts and graphs present key information in a user-friendly way.

donate_red_allcaps_black



Learn how CRI made a difference in 2023 through high-profile initiatives, legislative analysis and advocacy, and education and collaboration.






 

 

This counter represents the number of beverage cans and bottles that have been landfilled, littered and incinerated in the US so far this year
Scroll To Top